With The Medieval Soldier, Vesey Norman aims to explain the
organization of Western Europe’s military system during a period
that lies between the establishment of barbarian kingdoms in previous
territories of the Roman Empire and the fourteenth century. It is
undeniably a huge task for such a book, yet Norman tackles it despite
the difficulties. In order to reach his purpose, the author divides
his book in two parts. In the first third of the book Norman explores
the development of the first feudal (or proto-feudal) armies through
the analysis of four groups (Lombards,
Franks, Vikings, and Saxons). In the latter part, Norman goes deeper
in his study by exploring both the concepts of feudalism and chivalry,
using both a conceptual approach and the presentation of empirical
data.
The first part of the book is quite clear. In four chapters, each
of them dedicated to the study of the one of the barbarian peoples,
the author attempts to understand the evolution of medieval warfare
in different environments. The Lombards constitute
the first chapter, though oddly the author didn’t say too much
about them. In chapter 2, Norman analyses the military evolution
of the Franks from barbarian war-bands to an organized army under
a new hierarchical system which developed in their kingdom (i.e.,
feudalism). As the author says, the “essence of feudalism which
developed from these beginnings can be summed up as, “no privileges
without obligations, no duties without rights.” (25) He also
draws attention to the military reforms of Charlemagne and the development
and deepening of feudalism as a consequence of his campaigns. In
chapter 3, Norman evaluates the contribution of the Vikings to medieval
warfare, with a special emphasis given to their arms and their evolution.
In the last chapter of the first part of the book, the author pays
attention to the Saxons and their successful establishment in Britannia.
As he does for the other peoples, he also explores the issue of their
weaponry, observing their evolution and the consequent changes in
Saxon weaponry as a result of foreign influences (such as their adoption
of the Danish axe).
The second part of the book starts with a chapter about the concept
of feudalism. The author develops ideas presented in previous chapters
and shows the complexity of the mature feudal system through its
study in diverse contexts such as England or Germany. Chapter 6 is
related to the main characteristics and organization of this system:
in eight sub-topics, Norman explains how feudalism dealt with issues
like homage, service, castle-guard, scutage, mercenaries, military command, ordinances of war,
and the development of military forces in England. It is interesting
to see the attention given by the author to the Latin Kingdoms in
the Levant, or Crusaders States. In chapter 7, Norman raises questions
of chivalry and knighthood and the evolution of the knight, from
a mere cavalryman to a member of a hereditary caste, is the core
issue of this section. Moreover, the author goes further by considering
changes in the ideals of chivalry with the introduction of Christian
values. Finally, he examines the question of tournaments, first as
part of military training, practice combats and private exercises,
and then as public spectacles.
In chapter 8, the author attempts to outline the main military orders
present in Middle Ages: the Knights of Hospital, the Knights of the
Temple, and the Teutonic Knights, but also very briefly to other
orders existing in Spain at the time of Reconquista (Knights
of Calatrava; Knights of St. Julian del Pereyro;
and the Knights of St. James [of Santiago]). The last four chapters
of his book highlight a specific and important context in which
the medieval soldier participated: the Crusades. Therefore, chapter
9 is a summary of the first crusade (1096-1099) and the next chapter
presents the following crusading campaigns. In chapter 11, the author
examines the arms and armor of the crusaders and in the last chapter
Norman briefly described the ships used by crusaders. This picture
is still useful to understand sailing in Northern countries like
England as well as the Mediterranean (e.g., Venice).
The first impression I got when I began to read The Medieval
Soldier was a feeling of déjà-vu. It was
like Vesey Norman’s book was just another book about this
subject. However, and despite some similarities with other studies
of medieval warfare, it seems that The Medieval Soldier has
something different from the others. This difference resides in
the fact that it focuses on a specific and, perhaps, the most important
aspect of medieval culture of war: the soldier, the one who was
in the centre of fighting and battles. Is it something new? Well,
maybe it was a novelty in 1971, when it was first published. Today,
Norman’s book cannot be seen as something new in the field
of medieval warfare studies. Due to the fact that The Medieval
Soldier is a reprint, it is in partly out of date as reflected
in its bibliography, which is deficient in more recent studies
about this topic. Missing are books like Fighting Techniques
of the Medieval World: Equipment, Combat Skills and Tactics of
Matthew Bennett, Jim Bradbury and Kelly DeVries (2006); Medieval
Warfare of Helen Nicholson (2004); Warfare and Society in
Barbarian West, 450-900 of Guy Halsall (2003); Medieval
Warfare: A History, edited by Maurice Keen (1999); or Medieval
Military Technology of Kelly DeVries (1992),
just to refer to some of them. This lack of up-to-date references
can be seen as negative, especially for those who look to complement
this reading with other points of view and perspectives. Of course,
any specialist of medieval warfare, scholar or not, will be partially
disappointed. It doesn’t mean that this book has no merit;
on the contrary, Norman contribution to the understanding of the
evolution of the medieval soldier is extraordinary. And because
it focuses on the soldier and not exclusively on his arms and armor,
or in a particular geographical or chronological context, it must
be praised as a significant contribution to this field. Based on
the analysis of surviving weapons and armor as well as on medieval
documents, the author was able to present the medieval soldier
in a nutshell, almost. In fact, what I appreciate the most in Norman’s
book was the capacity of the author to be very clear in his statements
and this permanent reference to medieval sources and archaeological
evidences. To conclude, The Medieval Soldier is still a very interesting
book for both scholars and students of the history of medieval
warfare, but also for all of those who are interested in this subject.